[Editor's Note: Added to front page for discussion purposes. It's interesting, if nothing else.--C&F]
Texas-Texas A&M. dead.
Mizzou-Kansas. dead.
Pitt-West Va. dead.
Florida-Miami. dead.
Pitt-Penn St. dead.
Utah-BYU. dead.
Nebraska-Oklahoma. dead.
As a Clemson fan, I want to play Georgia, Auburn & Tennessee but with a 14-team conference & a 9-game conference schedule (plus Sakerlina), there's no room. We've had to cancel a series w/ Ole Miss & Oklahoma St b/c of this. We almost cancelled our 1st game vs Georgia since 2004 before both schools agreed on a $3 million buyout to play it next year & 2014. This will be the last time the 2 schools every play in the regular season IMO. We've played 57 times & are 74 miles apart.
There's a bunch of other examples. Here's my solution:
With 12, 14 & 16 team conferences, everyone can't play everyone. 10 games against 'BCS' competition is the max teams can do to make sure they have 7 home games. I would have more fun as a fan watching my school play the same 10 teams us fans consider our biggest rivals. So I propose a move to simple 8-team conferences.
A team plays the other 7 teams in its conference. They also play their 3 biggest rivals OOC annually for 10 games. This puts more of an emphasis on regional rivalries. Play the teams us fans care about. Then they can schedule their 2 cupcakes at home to make $.
In basketball, teams play each team in their conference 2x & their OOC rivals 2x for 14 conference games & 20 annual games. Then add in up to 10 cupcakes, early season tournaments & ACC-B1G challenges.
*The Mississippi, Washington & BEast teams have to fill in some rivalry games from the Metro & Mtn West conferences.
**Notre Dame plays a full 12 team schedule instead of 10 w/ Stan, USC, Mich, Mich St & Navy OOC.
Here's the Google Map for the new conferences.
Let's take a look at the SEC 1st - bold = conf member, next row = annual OOC Rival, miles away from each other & times played:
| SOUTHEASTERN | Rival 1 |
Rival 2 |
Rival 3 |
| Florida | FSU - 151 mi, 56x | Miami - 336 mi, 54x | Sakerlina - 354 mi, 32x |
| Georgia | Ga Tech - 70 mi, 101x | Sakerlina - 153 mi, 59x | Clemson - 74 mi, 57x |
| Tennessee | Kentucky - 170 mi, 104x | Vandy - 180 mi, 101x | Clemson - 195 mi, 18x |
| Auburn | Ga Tech - 110 mi, 86x | Clemson - 232 mi, 47x | FSU - 205 mi, 18x |
| Alabama | Vandy - 238 mi, 83x | Arkansas - 544 mi, 22x | Sakerlina - 416 mi, 15x |
| Mississippi | Memphis - 79 mi, 59x | TCU - 547 mi, 6x | Baylor - 564 mi, 1x |
| Mississippi State | Memphis - 174 mi, 44x | Baylor - 569 mi, 4x | TCU - 555 mi, 1x |
| Louisiana State | Arkansas - 563 mi, 56x | Texas - 431 mi, 15x | Baylor - 428 mi, 11x |
1932's Founding Fathers except for Vandy (private) & Kentucky (not in the south). Keeping it west of the Appalachians like they always intended. Allows Florida to play Miami, Georgia to play Clemson & Auburn to play Ga Tech & Clemson. Tenn still gets to play Kentucky & Vandy, plus Clemson, 74 miles away. The Mississippi's are in the heart of this SEC so not many regional rivals to choose from - they get Memphis & go out to Texas. Sakerlina still gets to play Florida, Georgia & now Bama. Arkansas keeps LSU & Bama.
| ATLANTIC COAST | Rival 1 |
Rival 2 |
Rival 3 |
| Florida State | Florida - 151 mi, 56x | Miami - 468 mi, 54x | Auburn - 205 mi, 18x |
| Georgia Tech | Georgia - 70 mi, 101x | Auburn - 110 mi, 86x | Miami - 663 mi, 17x |
| Clemson | Georgia - 74 mi, 57x | Auburn - 232 mi, 47x | Tenn - 195 mi, 18x |
|
South Carolina (SEC) |
Georgia - 153 mi, 59x | Florida - 354 mi, 32x | Bama - 416 mi, 15x |
| North Carolina | Wake - 77 mi, 99x | Duke - 11 mi, 91x | Maryland - 282 mi, 69x |
| North Carolina State | Wake - 107 mi, 104x | Duke - 25 mi, 81x | Maryland - 294 mi, 67x |
| Virginia | Maryland - 128 mi, 76x | Duke - 167 mi, 60x | Penn St - 284 mi, 6x |
| Virginia Tech | West Va - 250 mi, 51x | Wake - 103 mi, 36x | Pitt - 321 mi, 11x |
Sakerlina rejoins the ACC. ACC drops the dead weight (er, 5 private schools) & Pitt so it's focused on the south/mid-Atlantic. Now all 4 North Carolina schools get to play the other 3 annually. Clemson, FSU & Ga Tech can play other teams in the south. Virginia has a 4 hour drive to Happy Valley. Original member Maryland has to change conferences but keeps UNC, NCST & UVA on the annual schedule. Most importantly to Tobacco Road - all the basketball schools get to play each other 2x, including Duke-UNC.
| BIG EAST | |||
| Connecticut | Cuse - 270 mi, 8x | BC - 84 mi, 4x | USF - 1281 mi, 9x |
| Rutgers | Cuse - 237 mi, 39x | BC - 223 mi, 26x | Cincy - 628 mi, 17x |
|
Maryland (ACC) |
Virginia - 128 mi, 76x | UNC - 282 mi, 69x | NCST - 294 mi, 67x |
|
Penn State (B1G) |
Cuse - 229 mi, 70x | BC - 438 mi, 23x | Virginia - 284 mi, 11x |
|
Pittsburgh (ACC) |
Va Tech - 321 mi, 11x | L'ville - 388 mi, 15x | Cincy - 289 mi, 11x |
|
West Virginia (XII) |
Va Tech - 250 mi, 51x | Cincy - 304 mi, 20x | L'ville - 398 mi, 13x |
|
Ohio State (B1G) |
Michigan - 191 mi, 108x | Purdue - 239 mi, 54x | Mich St - 251 mi, 39x |
|
Kentucky (SEC) |
Tenn - 170 mi, 104x | Vandy - 174 mi, 101x | Indiana - 169 mi, 35x |
Here's the Eastern Conference JoePa always wanted. Penn St comes home & everyone else follows suit. Except for UConn in New England these 8 schools are very close together. Ohio St does leave the B1G but keeps Michigan, Mich St & Purdue on schedule. I don't know how much Columbus, OH cares about going past Illinois to play Midwestern teams. This is a lot closer playing all its' 5 border states PA, WV, KY, MI & IN. Kentucky plays 3 OOC schools 2.5 hours away +L'ville. Old BEast members Cuse, BC, L'ville & Cincy factor heavily into other teams OOC schedules. + NC & VA ACC teams.
| B1G | |||
| Michigan | Ohio St - 191 mi, 108x | NWern - 242 mi, 70x | ND - 169 mi, 36x |
| Michigan State | ND - 141 mi, 61x | NWern - 219 mi, 49x | Ohio St - 251 mi, 39x |
| Indiana | Kentucky - 169 mi, 35x | Mizzou - 439 mi, 10x | Kansas - 506 mi, 2x |
| Purdue | Ohio St - 239 mi, 54x | Kansas St - 606 mi, 3x | West Va - 443 mi, 2x |
| Illinois | NWern - 138 mi, 105x | Mizzou - 270 mi, 24x | Kansas - 432 mi, 5x |
| Wisconsin | Iowa St - 274 mi, 7x | Nebraska - 483 mi, 6x | Kansas St - 601 mi, 2x |
| Minnesota | Nebraska - 412 mi, 52x | Iowa St - 216 mi, 26x | Kansas - 476 mi, 7x |
| Iowa | Iowa St - 128 mi, 54x | Nebraska - 305 mi, 31x | Mizzou - 316 mi, 4x |
Like the SEC, the B1G sheds some teams away from its footprint & doesn't bring anyone new in. Ohio St & Northwestern each have 3 games w/ their original conferences. This emphasizes a B1G vs Big VIII Midwest rivalry. Except for Michigan (only B1G schools in EST) everyone else goes Midwest w/ their OOC schedules vs Mizzou, Kansas, K-St, Iowa St & Nebraska. They're all in central time zone & haven't played as much as you'd think. Indiana gets a piece of some strong basketball teams: Kentucky, Mizzou & Kansas.
| BIG VIII | |||
| Oklahoma | Texas - 372 mi, 96x | A&M - 357 mi, 29x | Tx Tech - 343 mi, 19x |
| Oklahoma State | Tx Tech - 413 mi, 39x | A&M - 425 mi, 26x | Texas - 440 mi, 26x |
|
Arkansas (SEC) |
A&M - 472 mi, 67x | LSU - 563 mi, 56x | Bama - 544 mi, 22x |
|
Missouri (SEC) |
Illinois - 270 mi, 24x | Indiana - 439 mi, 10x | Iowa - 316 mi, 4x |
| Kansas | Minn - 476 mi, 7x | Illinois - 432 mi, 5x | Indiana - 506 mi, 2x |
|
Kansas State |
Tx Tech - 594 mi, 12x | Purdue - 606 mi, 3x | Wisc - 601 mi, 2x |
| Nebraska (B1G) | Minn - 412 mi, 52x | Iowa - 305 mi, 31x | Wisc - 483 mi, 6x |
| Iowa State | Iowa - 128 mi, 54x | Minn - 216 mi, 26x | Wisc - 274 mi, 7x |
Big VIII is back & with 1 change - Arkansas instead of Colorado. Mizzou, Kansas, K-St, Nebraska & Iowa St have their OOC filled w/ B1G Illinoi, Indiana, Wisc, Minn & Iowa. The Oklahoma schools player their old Big XII South division rivals - the 3 public Texas schools. Arkansas plays it's biggest rival Texas A&M & keeps the big 2 SEC teams on its' schedule - Bama/LSU.
| PRIVATE | |||
|
Boston College (ACC) |
Rutgers - 223 mi, 26x | Penn St - 438 mi, 23x | UConn - 84 mi, 4x |
| Syracuse (ACC) | Penn St - 229 mi, 70x | Rutgers - 237 mi, 39x | UConn - 270 mi, 8x |
|
Notre Dame (Ind) |
Stanford/USC | Michigan/Mich St | Navy - 663 mi, 85x |
|
Northwestern (B1G) |
Illinois - 138 mi, 105x | Michigan - 242 mi, 70x | Mich St - 219 mi, 49x |
|
Vanderbilt (SEC) |
Kentucky - 174 mi, 101x | Tenn - 180 mi, 101x | Bama - 238 mi, 83x |
|
Wake Forest (ACC) |
NCST - 107 mi, 104x | UNC - 77 mi, 99x | Va Tech - 103 mi, 36x |
|
Duke (ACC) |
UNC - 11 mi, 91x | NCST - 25 mi, 81x | Virginia - 167 mi, 60x |
|
Miami (ACC) |
Florida - 336 mi, 54x | FSU - 468 mi, 54x | Ga Tech - 663 mi, 17x |
The 8 strongest private schools are here in a new conference. 5 from the ACC + the token private schools from SEC & B1G + ND. NWern keeps in state Illinois & the Michigan schools & Vandy keeps it's closest SEC rivals - Tenn, Kentucky & Bama. Cuse & BC have a northeastern focus w/ Rutgers, UConn & Penn St. Wake & Duke get to play UNC & NCST. Miami can play Florida again & the other big city in the south Ga Tech in Atlanta (Braves-Marlins, Hawks-Heat anyone?).
ND keeps a national footprint against elite academic, like-minded schools. Stanford & USC in Cali, regional games vs Mich, Mich-St &Northwestern in Chicago. Head south to Nashville. Annual game in NC. Northeast vs Cuse (in NYC?) & vs other Catholics, BC in Boston. Catholics vs Convicts in Miami. Keeps annual game vs Navy. Only traditional rival they lose is in-state Purdue.
| SOUTHWEST | |||
|
Texas (XII) |
Oklahoma - 372 mi, 96x | Ok St - 440 mi, 26x | LSU - 431 mi, 15x |
|
Texas A&M (SEC) |
Arkansas - 472 mi, 67x | Oklahoma - 357 mi, 29x | Ok St - 425 mi, 26x |
|
Texas Tech (XII) |
Ok St - 413 mi, 39x | Oklahoma - 343 mi, 19x | Kansas St - 594 mi, 12x |
|
Colorado (PAC) |
Oregon - 1262 mi, 16x | UCLA - 1038 mi, 7x | Cal - 1245 mi, 6x |
|
Utah (PAC) |
Oregon - 773 mi, 26x | UCLA - 692 mi, 10x | Cal - 729 mi, 8x |
|
Brigham Young (Ind) |
Ore St - 824 mi, 10x | USC - 648 mi, 2x | Stanford - 778 mi, 2x |
|
Arizona (PAC) |
Oregon - 1268 mi, 37x | UCLA - 486 mi, 35x | Cal - 859 mi, 30x |
|
Arizona State (PAC) |
Ore St - 1220 mi, 38x | USC - 382 mi, 28x | Stanford - 738 mi, 27x |
The Southwest Conference is also back from the dead (RIP 1996). Texas gets to play the other 2 big state schools, both Oklahoma schools & goes west w/ Colorado, Utah & Arizona. BYU finally lands in a good conference. SWC & PAC have a lot of matchups here. I sent all the western schools to LA, Bay Area & PacNW. These opponents could rotate since there's a lot to choose from.
| PACIFIC | |||
| California | Arizona - 859 mi, 30x | Utah - 729 mi, 8x | Colorado - 1245 mi, 6x |
| Stanford | Ariz St - 738 mi, 27x | ND - 2244 mi, 26x | BYU - 778 mi, 2x |
| UCLA | Arizona - 486 mi, 35x | Utah - 692 mi, 10x | Colorado - 1038 mi, 7x |
| USC | ND - 2095 mi, 83x | Ariz St - 382 mi, 28x | BYU - 648 mi, 2x |
| Oregon | Arizona - 1268 mi, 37x | Utah - 773 mi, 26x | Colorado - 1262 mi, 16x |
| Oregon State | Ariz St - 1220 mi, 38x | BYU - 824 mi, 10x | Boise St - 440 mi, 7x |
| Washington | Air Force - 1393 mi, 8x | Hawaii - 4x | Boise St - 504 mi, 1x |
| Washington State | UNLV - 950 mi, 5x | Hawaii - 5x | Boise St - 299 mi, 4x |
This is the original PAC 8. OOC is almost entirely vs Arizona, Ariz St, Utah, BYU & Colorado. Private Standford & USC play private ND & BYU. Boise St gets a stronger schedule w/ 3 PAC teams. There wasn't much left for Washington schools so they get an every other year trip to Hawaii & could play AF or UNLV. Wash St is pretty terrible, makes it easier for them in the middle of nowhere.
& the rest of the conferences...
| METRO | |||
| South Florida (BEast) | UConn - 1281 mi, 9x | ECU | Tulane |
| Central Florida (BEast) | UAB | ECU | Tulane |
| Cincinnati (BEast) | West Va - 304 mi, 20x | Rutgers - 628 mi, 17x | Pitt - 289 mi, 11x |
| Louisville (BEast) | Kentucky - 76 mi, 18x | Pitt - 388 mi, 15x | West Va - 398 mi, 13x |
| Memphis (BEast) | Ole Miss - 79 mi, 59x | Miss St - 174 mi, 44x | UAB |
| Houston (BEast) | Rice - 38x | SMU - 27x | UTEP - 7x |
|
Baylor (XII) |
LSU - 428 mi, 11x | Miss St - 569 mi, 4x | Ole Miss - 564 mi, 1x |
|
Texas Christian (XII) |
Ole Miss - 547 mi, 6x | Miss St - 555 mi, 1x | SMU - 90x |
7/8 of these teams have been added to the BEast since 2005. Most of them came from the Metro (CUSA) before that. If a team not from the above 8 conferences is going to have a big season it'll either be Boise St or a team from the Metro. Most of these are commuter colleges in big cities not known for their academics. Except for Baylor & TCU which didn't fit in the SWC or Private conferences. Memphis, Baylor & TCU take on Ole Miss & Miss St annually. Cincy & L'ville play current BEast teams OOC.
| CONFERENCE USA | |||
| East Carolina | USF | UCF | Charlotte |
| UAB | Memphis | UCF | Ga St |
| Southern Miss | N Texas | Texas St | UTSA |
| Tulane | USF | UCF | FIU |
| Louisiana Tech | N Texas | Texas St | UTSA |
| Rice | Houston - 38x | FAU | FIU |
| SMU (BEast) | TCU - 90x | Houston - 27x | UTEP - 15x |
| Tulsa | N Texas | Texas St | NMST |
These teams weren't good enough to get a BEast invite, except for SMU. They're a big loser here, along w/ Temple. They do get to play 4 games in Texas annually plus an occasional game against Texas/A&M/Tech. All of these teams are in the Central time zone except for ECU, which is a long way from Birmingham.
| MOUNTAIN WEST | |||
|
UTEP (CUSA) |
SMU - 17x | Air Force - 15x | Houston - 7x |
| New Mexico | NMST - 77x | Air Force - 29x | Utah St - 19x |
| Colorado State | Utah St - 68x | Air Force - 50x | Fresno St - 11x |
| Wyoming | Utah St - 62x | Air Force - 50x | Fresno St - 27x |
|
Boise State (BEast) |
Ore St - 440 mi, 7x | Wash St - 299 mi, 4x | Wash - 504 mi, 1x |
| UNLV | Nevada - 20x | Air Force - 17x | Wash St - 5x |
| San Diego State (BEast) | Air Force - 30x | Fresno St - 20x | SJST - 16x |
| Hawaii | Air Force - 18x | Wash St - 5x | Wash - 4x |
MWC rejoices w/ Boise St & SDST staying put. UTEP comes back finally & gets to play in Houston or Dallas annually. Air Force goes Ind. but plays everyone OOC except for Boise St. Boise's OOC schedule is a lot stronger w/ Ore St, Wash & Wash St. Rest of the schools play a lot of WAC.
| WESTERN ATHLETIC | |||
|
North Texas (CUSA) |
LA Tech | SoMiss | Tulsa |
|
Texas State (SUN) |
LA Tech | SoMiss | Tulsa |
| UTSA (CUSA) | LA Tech | SoMiss | Tulsa |
| New Mexico State |
NM - 77x | Idaho | |
|
Utah State (MWC) |
Colorado St - 68x | Wyoming - 62x | Idaho |
| Nevada (MWC) | UNLV - 20x | Idaho | |
| San Jose State (MWC) | SDST - 16x | Idaho | |
| Fresno State (MWC) | SDST - 20x | Idaho |
This may be the only way the WAC stays alive & Idaho still doesn't get an invite! The only team here that hasn't been in the WAC is North Texas. SDST/SJST/Fresno St get to play each other for a JV State Championship.
| SUN BELT | |||
| Florida Int'l (CUSA) |
Rice | Temple | Tulane |
| Florida Atlantic | Rice | Temple | Charlotte |
| South Alabama | Charlotte | ||
| Troy | Charlotte | ||
| Georgia State | UAB | Charlotte | |
| Middle Tennessee | Marshall | LAMO | LALA |
| Western Kentucky | Marshall | LAMO | LALA |
| Arkansas State | Rice | LAMO | LALA |
Sun Belt without the Louisiana schools. USA & Ga St jump up from FCS.
| NORTHEAST | |||
| Buffalo (MAC) | Army | UMass | EMU |
| Akron (MAC) | Miami | Toledo | BG |
| Kent State (MAC) | Miami | Toledo | BG |
|
Ohio (MAC) |
Miami | Toledo | BG |
|
Marshall (CUSA) |
W Kentucky | MTSU | Charlotte |
|
Temple (BEast) |
Old Dominion | CMU/WMU |
Villanova |
| Delaware (FCS) | Old Dominion | CMU | WMU |
|
James Madison (FCS) |
Old Dominion | CMU | WMU |
ECU might be happier in this divisions. Temple's a big loser in this since they'll be in the BE in 2012.
| MID-AMERICAN | |||
| Miami | Akron | Kent St | Ohio |
| Toledo | Akron | Kent St | Ohio |
| Bowling Green | Akron | Kent St | Ohio |
| Eastern Michigan | Army | Buffalo | UMass |
| Central Michigan | JMU | Delaware | Temple |
| Western Michigan | JMU | Delaware | Temple |
| Ball State | Army | UMass |
|
| Northern Illinois | Army | UMass |
The MAC minus the 3 eastern Ohio schools & Buffalo. All the Ohio schools play all the Ohio schools in the Buckeye JV State Championship.
| INDEPENDENTS | ||||
|
Air Force (MWC) |
7 MWC | Navy/Army | Wash | |
|
Navy (BEast) |
ND/Army/Air Force |
SDST/Hawaii | Maryland | |
|
Army |
Navy/Air Force |
Buffalo | Ball St/N Illinois | |
|
EMU | Ball St | N Illinois | |
| Old Dominion (CUSA) | JMU | Delaware | Temple | |
| Charlotte (CUSA) | ECU | Marshall | GA St | |
| LA-Lafayette (SUN) | Ark St | MTSU | W Kentucky | |
|
LA-Monroe (SUN) |
Ark St | MTSU | W Kentucky | |
|
Idaho (WAC) |
NMST/Utah St | Boise St/Nevada | SJST/Fresno St |
Leftover teams. UMass, OD & Charlotte are jumping up from FCS. Idaho is considering dropping down. LAMO & LALA are the 4th & 5th schools IN LA. Business as usual for Army.
Thoughts?
A FanPost gives the opinion of the fan who writes it and that fan only. That doesn't give the opinion more or less weight than any other opinion on this blog, but the post does not necessarily reflect the view of TSK's writers.
There are 22 Comments. Load Now.
Shortcuts to mastering the comment thread. Use wisely.
C - Next Comment
X - Mark as Read
R - Reply
Z - Mark Read & Next
Shift + C - Previous
Shift + A - Mark All Read
Comment Settings
Live comment alert: Hide it!
Comments for this post are closed.