Kiffin's Departure Not a Big Surprise
When Tennessee hired him, I asked the question, "Is Lane Kiffin really the best Tennessee could do?" I guess at this point, we all know the answer: almost certainly not.
In hindsight, this really couldn't have ended up any other way. Just what did you expect when:
- His SID at USC publicly warned schools not to hire him (twice),and incidentally now thinks USC's program committed suicide.
- He decided the best way to get out of Oakland was to act like a petulant child (antagonizing his bosses, going for a 76 yard field goal, etc.) rather than work things out like an adult. He forced the team to fire him so he could collect buyout money instead of just resigning.
- He broke one of the cardinal rules of coaching, namely that you don't start talking unless you've won something recently. Even Steve Spurrier follows that one.
- He attempted to show his knowledge of Tennessee's program by going after Florida, a relatively recent rival, while all but kissing up to Nick Saban and Alabama (calling UAT the best coached team in the conference on multiple occasions), the much older and more hated rival.
- He went so far as to replace Tennessee traditions with stuff he got from USC.
- His idea of pushing the limits was to break rules and then apologize later, instead of exploiting loopholes like Saban and Urban Meyer have been known to do.
I'm wondering if I should read too much into the fact that he said in his one-minute press conference last night that USC was "probably" the only job he'd leave Tennessee for. Even if it was inadvertent, it only fits in with everything else.
I feel bad for Tennessee's players. They deserve better than this, and it's possible that all the coaching turnover could ruin the NFL chances (or at least future draft positioning) for some of them. I feel bad for Phillip Fulmer, who had to watch his beloved program get taken over by a hack who skipped town at the first opportunity.
I don't feel quite as bad for Tennessee fans. The warning signs were all there, and having seen the Ron Zook era at Florida in person as a student, I know for a fact there's no rule that says a fanbase must embrace the head football coach no matter who he is. Everyone else in the conference tried to warn you. Kiffin himself practically tried to warn you with all his words and actions. He deserved the cold shoulder treatment from fans far more than Zook ever did.
Even if USC was Kiffin's dream job, he didn't have to take it now. I know you can make the case for USC being a better job than Tennessee's, but UT isn't a stepping stone school. If he stayed around Knoxville longer, accomplished something, and then chose to go out to USC when the job opens up somewhere down the line, I doubt anyone would blame him for it. It is reportedly his dream job.
However even in this era of mercenary coaches, we've seen guys turn down dream jobs to honor their commitments and schools. Les Miles turned down his alma mater to stay at LSU. Meyer has passed on Notre Dame twice now for Florida. Chris Petersen, Gary Patterson, and Bronco Mendenhall have all even passed up BCS school jobs to continue their work at their current posts.
Kiffin going out to USC is in a different class even than Bobby Petrino leaving the Falcons or Saban leaving the Dolphins. In those cases, the guys tried coaching on a different level, found out it wasn't for them, and left for places they'd feel passionate about. Kiffin clearly went to Tennessee for the money and to get his career back on track, not because he held it in any kind of high esteem.
Tennessee will now have to go find a new coach three weeks before signing day. If the school is desperate, it will go after Fulmer or one of his former assistants like David Cutcliffe or John Chavis. I say that because moving on from Fulmer was the right decision for the long term health of the program. It was who they got to replace him that was bad. If the school is smart, it will make a Godfather offer (i.e. one that cannot be refused) to an up and coming coach who will be grateful for the opportunity and will actually embrace the school.
As for Kiffin, he's now more than ever cemented himself as a story that college football will be dealing with for more than the next quarter century. He's not even old enough to be elected president, and he's on his third head coaching job already. Any bets as to how many more he'll have before he's done?
0 recs |
20 comments
|
Comments
Not to take a leak on a grave, but...
Screw Willie Martinez for getting us rung up by this jerk.
by D.N. Nation on Jan 13, 2010 11:51 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
You realize that your offense never made it past the 30 yard line.
IIRC, WM didn’t coach them.
by Incipient_Senescence on Jan 13, 2010 2:51 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
It was a total fail by UGA...
but that was among the worst defensively called games I’ve seen at this level. It was comical.
UT’s gameplan:
Play A: Handoff up the middle/off tackle.
Play B: Rollout for first down pass.
Repeat until victorious.
UGA did nothing to stop a play that came almost every other down. No backside pressure, nothing. That was the game I realized that UGA fans were not exaggerating about WM’s awfulness.
by Giant Catfish on Jan 13, 2010 2:55 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
As a bama fan
all I can say is welcome to our world. Franchone was probably a better coach than Kiffin, but to be shown the total lack of respect like this, well, it feels like when we heard Fran’s wife Kim said something like “Thank God we got out of Alabama!” It was a total insult, and I’m glad the man fell on his face at TA&M.
Cheer up, Tenn guys. You aren’t on probation like we were, and with a halfway decent hire, you’ll be back in it again in no time. Good luck, things can work out for you.
"It's not the size of the dog in the fight, it's the size of the fight in the dog." - Bear Bryant
by NJBammer on Jan 13, 2010 11:55 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
Yet
They’re not on probation yet.
Team Speed Kills. All SEC, all the time.
by cocknfire on Jan 13, 2010 12:23 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
One more job
In the unlikely event that he’s successful at Southern Cal, his only move would be to try the NFL again a la Carroll. If he fails, he’s done; no other school would hire someone with his track record if he can’t win in LA.
Team Speed Kills. All SEC, all the time.
by cocknfire on Jan 13, 2010 12:24 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
I don't think that's necessarily true.
There’s always someone out there who’s desperate. He’ll never be back in the SEC, though; I think we can agree on that
by dxf04 on Jan 13, 2010 12:39 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
If he fails
He’s likely to end up at a smaller school on his way out the ass end of the FBS. If he is, god forbid, successful at said small school, he will not be asked to take a high profile job anywhere. There will be a ceiling and he’ll probably get pissy and just quit.
by knowshon loves legos on Jan 13, 2010 1:27 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
That was (sorta) my point.
If he fails at USC (and by fail, I mean USC’s standard of fail, i.e., no BCS, can’t beat UCLA or UC-Berk, inexplicable losses to Arizon St., all on the way to a 8-4 or 9-3 finish), there’s a good chance that he could end up somewhere like New Mexico, maybe somewhere in the WAC (Fresno is a huge possibility, frankly). If he does have success at one of these “lower” jobs, I see nothing stopping him from getting a “high profile” job at somewhere like Washington, Wash. St., TTU, TAMU, or anyone of that stature who is hit with a sudden loss of coach and is “desperate”.
by dxf04 on Jan 13, 2010 3:20 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
TV would hire him
If there’s a job for Matt Millen, there’s a job for any failed coach/executive with connections.
by The Bengal on Jan 14, 2010 5:28 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I'm normally not one to wallow in a rival's misfortunes.
But you deserve no sympathy, Vol fans. I feel bad for the players, and I feel really bad for Bray, but the fans had every reason to know something like this was coming. Examine the stuff you stuck up for him about. The cheating accusations, the ridiculous prodding of vastly superior programs and qualified, proved-it-on-the-field coaches. The absurd gloating of “I can’t you hear you, Rocky Top is playing” after losing to UF. That was the dumbest, most cynical, idiotic, narcissistic, and ultimately hilarious thing I’ve ever heard. He never cared about winning, he wanted to look just good enough to get consideration at a job like USC. Once heads cool off a little bit, I’ll ask RTT if they still think Kiffy/UT “is in Meyer’s head.”
Perhaps it was because UT hadn’t had a new coach in such a long time, and therefore was inexperienced in navigating this new world of me-first, spotlight loving coaches, but this result (or something worse) was inevitable.
USC is screwed.
by Giant Catfish on Jan 13, 2010 2:50 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
your last sentence is correct. the guy is a proven liar
i love how some espn people were saying this was a good hire for the trojans. (cough, spit) only b/c espn like’s the idea of propping up usc (b/c they need the cali market, 38 million strong)so they don’t end up like notre dame. p.s. matt barkley please take the wind sprints to heart in spring drills b/c my guess is you will be doing alot of running away from would be tackler’s. lol.
i'm all about covering the spread and moneylines. i was building a house, i don't deserve this, deserves have nothing to do with it. bang. "unforgiven"
by wolfmanshowlforever on Jan 13, 2010 5:50 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I'm not sure I follow this
Even if USC was Kiffin’s dream job, he didn’t have to take it now. I know you can make the case for USC being a better job than Tennessee’s, but UT isn’t a stepping stone school. If he stayed around Knoxville longer, accomplished something, and then chose to go out to USC when the job opens up somewhere down the line, I doubt anyone would blame him for it. It is reportedly his dream job.
So you shouldn’t take your dream job when it is first offered to you – you should instead stay where you are to accomplish something and then hope your dream job is offered to you again??!?!
Why?
USC is one of THE best jobs in the country. You have a fantastic recruiting base with little competition. Plus, don’t you think Layla would be much happier in So Cal than in East Tennessee??!?!
I think USC is the foolish party here – not Kiffin. He left for a better position in a better locale for more money. Wouldn’t most (all) of us do that same?
by skigator93 on Jan 13, 2010 5:50 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
If you’re working on a long term project at your work, you don’t leave for a new job three weeks before that project is done. Or at least, you work out a deal with the new employer to finish that project. Any reasonable company worth the label of “dream job” would understand.
In college coaching, there is no equivalent to that when it comes to recruiting. You can agree to stay on through a bowl, but you can’t agree to stay on through the end of recruiting season. It just won’t work. This wouldn’t have been so bad had Carroll split before the bowls and Kiffin had been hired then, but the Seattle job wasn’t open back then.
Team Speed Kills
SBNation's SEC Blog
by Year2 on Jan 14, 2010 8:00 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Still not following
So Carroll is the bad guy for leaving when he did – not Kiffin. When your dream job opens, and it offered to you, you take it. Period. You can’t tell a company “well, I appreciate the offer, but I have to finish this project at my current employer (which includes trying to steal potential employees away from your company who have verbally committed already). Surely you understand, right?”
No. They do not understand. You just threw away your chance at your dream job.
I am not sure what you do for a living, but let’s just say that you were offered a new job, at double your current salary, to move to Hawaii and oil up Hawaiian Tropic bikini models for their photo shoots. Hey? Where’d he go???!
by skigator93 on Jan 14, 2010 11:59 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Hmmm
Im sure UT will wait until after NSD 2/3/10 to hire their new coach, Ya right, who by the way will leave their team during this critical recruitng period.
Of course not. They are now looking to fill there job and other team will do the same.
by WE ARE SC on Jan 14, 2010 9:12 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I never thought I could wish well to Tennessee
After I saw my dawgs get throttled by the man I’ve learned to loathe, I thought Tennessee had returned to the top spot of my most hated rivals. Now that I see what a shambles Kiffin made of their traditions and a Dooley at the helm to regain their stature, I have to say I’ll wish them well in every game but the one played in Sanford Stadium. We only get great by great competition, and no SEC school deserves what Tennessee got.
by stretchdavis on Jan 19, 2010 3:50 PM EST reply actions 0 recs

by 










