SEC 2000-10: The Best Player -- Tim Tebow
Thanks to a lot of reasons—big time recruiters inhabiting the coaching ranks, the general population shift southward, a disproportionately large number of storied programs, etc.—the SEC has seen a lot of fantastic players at every position over the last decade. One stands out from all the rest though: Tim Tebow.
It's difficult to say whether then-UF co-defensive coordinator Greg Mattison was correct in saying during the recruiting process that Florida's program would be set back 10 years if it didn't sign Tebow. It certainly would have made things a lot different had he chosen to go to his runner up school, Alabama. Mike Shula might still be in Tuscaloosa, Nick Saban would be at some other place, and Florida would have gone into 2006 spring practice with Chris Leak as the only scholarship quarterback. It's one of the conference's greatest what ifs.
However, he did end up in Gainesville and things would not be the same. Florida definitely does not win the 2006 national championship without him as DeShawn Wynn and Kestahn Moore were not picking up all those crucial third downs that season. He became the first sophomore ever to win the Heisman Trophy in his 2007 campaign, paving the way for Sam Bradford and Mark Ingram to win it the following two years. He led the 2008 Florida squad to one of the best seasons ever in the SEC, as no team has won as many in-conference games by 28+ points (seven) or by 30+ points (six) as that one did. In 2009, it didn't end the way it was expected but he still helped get Florida to its second ever 12-0 start and pushed the school's record winning streak to 22 in a row.
That 2007 Heisman winning season was easily his best individually. He passed for 3,286 yards at a 66.9% completion rate, both career highs. He accounted for three or more touchdowns in 12 of the team's 13 games, including a ridiculous seven against South Carolina. He about single-handedly won that year's Ole Miss and Kentucky games. He became the first player ever to score 20 passing and 20 rushing touchdowns in a season. He had 51 touchdowns by the time Heisman ballots were in...
...and he tacked on four more in the Capital One Bowl to push his season total to 55. If Florida had a reasonable semblance of a defense, the Gators would have been in the thick of the national title race.
![]() |
| TUESDAY: What a Decade It's Been; Mike Price's Trip to Pensacola |
| WEDNESDAY: The Zook Experiment; Georgia Hires Mark Richt |
| THURSDAY: The Best Game; Auburn's Rise and Fall; Rivalry of the Decade |
| FRIDAY: The Worst Game; The Rise of the Nicktator; The Promise |
| TODAY: Exit Phil Fulmer |
In 2008 his yardage and scoring totals came down a bit, but the team success was up. It took a couple of games to get going, but once all the pieces were in place around Tebow (and after a loss and The Promise refocused things), the scoring began to increase at a frightening pace. The regular season was capped off by Tebow's signature game, the SEC Championship Game against Alabama. He three three touchdown passes, all on third down and two of which were in the fourth quarter. It was a tour de force and the sort of game where you could tell that he would not let his team lose.
Tebow returned in 2009 to win another championship, but ghastly levels of attrition at wide receiver, a new offensive coordinator, problems with blitz protection, and an inexplicable defensive collapse at the worst possible time kept it from being the season to remember that everyone figured it would be. Urban Meyer put nearly all the load on him in the SEC title game rematch with Alabama, as 45 of the Gators' 49 plays were either passes or Tebow rushes. He came through to the tune of nearly seven yards per play on Bama's great defense and five trips inside the Tide 30 on nine possessions. Without any defensive support whatsoever, it was like 2007 all over again. There's only so much one man, even Tim Tebow, can do by himself.
Even so, he's the only quarterback to play in three SEC Championship Games and two national title games this decade. He brought back the jump pass, invented the one-man play action, and added "Tebow smash" to our lexicon.
He was 11-1 as a starter against Florida's big three rivals and 15-1 overall against them (not to mention 3-1 against LSU). He delivered Mark Richt and Steve Spurrier their worst losses as head coaches, Rich Brooks' second worst loss as a head coach, Les Miles' worst loss at LSU, and Bobby Bowden's worst loss to Florida since 1983. He's been the face of college football for two seasons. And as much as Tebow fatigue wore on people around the conference and nation, he still received the highest of compliments from about all rival fans: they have warned for almost two years now that they'd get Florida just as soon as Tebow leaves. Once he's gone, they say, watch out.
That is why Tim Tebow is the SEC player of the decade.
0 recs |
9 comments
|
Comments
Not a bad post
but saying Tebow would have saved Shula’s job is laughable. I can’t imagine how awful it would be to watch Tebow try to operate a traditional offense. A 3-step drop QB he is not. And as great as he was at Florida, he was without a doubt (with USC maybe having an argument) surrounded by the best collection of talent in CF for his four year tenure.
With that said, he is/was a hell of a player and will always be heralded in the annals of UF history and will probably go down as a top-5 player in CF history before it’s all said and done.
by TheRZA on Dec 21, 2009 12:24 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
The guy has one of the highest work ethics I’ve seen in a college football player. I’ll bet he could do it (though without looking as comfortable as he was in the spread option). He can do it in the NFL too, but it won’t happen within the next two years.
Team Speed Kills
SBNation's SEC Blog
by Year2 on Dec 21, 2009 2:07 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Tebow's mechanics
Looked worse this year than they did in 2007, and worse against Bama than they had all season.
Good on him for the work ethic, I suppose. He’ll need it. But it won’t be enough under center. And it didn’t really show w/r/t NFL prospects this season.
by D.N. Nation on Dec 21, 2009 3:59 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Exactly.
Work ethic never guarantees success and seeing him throw for four years proves that. I’m not questioning his greatness as a college quarterback, rather, him being a quarterback that can play under center after NEVER going under center, for even a snap, in college. Year2 would even have to admit that throwing never was/never will be his strong suit, which is why I doubt his ability to succeed in the NFL as a QB. That same work ethic should suit him well in a transition to, say, TE or something of that nature though. And don’t consider me a Tebow hater, because I’m not. I recognize his greatness and he has definitely secured his niche in history, but if you’re being a realist, you would admit to yourself he’s not likely to succeed. I hope he does, and makes a fool out of me.
by TheRZA on Dec 21, 2009 6:45 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Tebow has taken snaps from under center
I can remember a couple times, but of course he handed it off, and didn’t drop pack and throw a pass.
Gator Bait: The first, and still the best.
by colombo259 on Dec 21, 2009 9:02 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I can see him as a TE or an H-back and a Wildcat QB
But unless he can fix those mechanics, I agree that he has limited pro prospects as a QB.
Team Speed Kills. All SEC, all the time.
by cocknfire on Dec 21, 2009 11:31 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Looked worse
That was a nasty comment on a player that has accomplished more than any of your college football heros. Everyone’s opinion has value and so does yours, I suppose.
by renegator on Dec 21, 2009 9:12 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Word on the street is that Tebow really didn’t want to change too much for his last year, and Meyer himself told Scot Loeffler not to “mess him up.” The fairly hands off quarterback coaching combined with the regression of the offensive line meant that a lot of his bad habits came out this season.
In that sense, it’s good for him and his development that he’ll be getting away from Meyer. He can get things worked out, but it will take a couple of years sitting on the bench and working in practice to get it all right. If he goes to a franchise that expects him to play right away, then I put the odds of failure at 90% or higher. If he gets to sit and learn, practice, and develop for a while, then the odds are much higher.
Yeah, there’s no way he’s winning rookie of the year in 2010. That’s for sure. But I can remember people saying that he couldn’t throw the ball well enough to succeed in the SEC, and he turned out just fine. He’s in a similar spot as Vince Young was coming out of college: bad mechanics, running instinct, local legend. VY’s much better now four years in than he was right out of college as he’s learned how to become an NFL quarterback, and Tebow won’t go through a moody phase like he did. It won’t happen immediately, but it can if he’s treated right.
Team Speed Kills
SBNation's SEC Blog
by Year2 on Dec 22, 2009 9:53 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I think Tebow's NFL career will hinge on which team selects him
If he does indeed go to Jacksonville, it’s game over. 2009 showed how a leaky offensive line can limit his passing ability. Garrard has gotten little to no pass protection in critical situations (ie 3rd down and red zone) this year. Also, the offensive system by Del Rio and Koetter does not suit Garrard as a mobile quarterback, so it’s probably not a good match for Tebow, either.
However, if he goes to the Patriots, he can study as Tom Brady’s backup, watch plenty of fillm, and have time to develop his mechanics and reads. Not to mention, the Patriots run as close to the spread as I’ve seen in the NFL.
by GoGators15 on Dec 22, 2009 11:24 AM EST reply actions 0 recs

by 











