So Much for Conference Supremacy: ACC rolls and other Week 14 action

Not exactly what we had in mind.
If the title of this post has a familiar ring to it, that's intentional. Back in mid-October, after Florida blew LSU out of the water in a 51-21 shellacking, the weekly wrap-up was titled "So Much for Western Supremacy."
As damaging as LSU's loss was to the notion that the SEC West was the stronger half of the league, Saturday's triple defeat at the hands of the ACC was an even worse setback for the idea that the SEC is the best conference in the land. Just moments after South Carolina fell 31-14 to Clemson, Georgia ended a 45-42 loss at the hands of Georgia Tech. Wake Forest's 23-10 victory over Vanderbilt hours later clinched a losing record for the SEC against its neighboring BCS league, a conference that national and local pundits alike had mocked for weeks.
Is the ACC better than the SEC? Probably not. Given the up-again, down-again pattern followed by most of ACC's teams, all three of those games could end differently if the games were played again this week. And the weekend was not the kind of head-to-head match-up that would have seen the top-rated ACC team take on the top-rated SEC team and on down the line.
But the games will not be played this week, and no such SEC-ACC tournament is scheduled. The best conference in America does not go 4-6 against the ACC in a season, nor does it go 1-3 in a weekend. You'll have to look for someone else.
Florida, in the meantime, was Florida. They amassed 502 yards to Florida State's 242, ran the ball 46 for 317 yards (6.9 ypc) and, as usual, had scored enough points by late in the first half (21 at the 5:33 mark) to win the game. The final margin -- 45-15 -- was proof that the Gators are playing on a different plane than anyone else in the SEC, save Alabama.
Not that everything came out the way the Gators had hoped: Percy Harvin is questionable for the SEC Championship Game. Though, as Nick Saban points out, that's not exactly a reason for Alabama to hold a parade.
"They really have three players. ... No. 1 (Harvin), No. 2 (Jeff Demps) and No. 3 (Chris Rainey). It's easy to remember. They're all outstanding players with big-play ability. They also have outstanding receivers and a Heisman-winning quarterback (Tim Tebow). They utilize all those players in different roles."Certainly, we respect Percy Harvin as a great player. But they have some other great players, too."
Alabama, for its part, dismantled Auburn 36-0 on Saturday, gaining 412 yards to Auburn's 170, earning 21 first downs to the Tiger's eight and finishing off Auburn's talk of various thumbs and fingers. The most suprising statistics in the game: Mario Fannin's longest rush was for eight yards, as was Brad Lester's. Ben Tate's long run was for three yards. A 13-yard run by Kodi Burns would be the longest run of the day.
There's not much more to explain from this weekend. For the time, at least, the SEC is a two-team league. Those teams will meet Saturday, in the game everyone has anticipated now for weeks. Everything else is detail.
OTHER WEEKEND RECAPS AT TSK:
And Phil Fades Away -- Tennessee 28, Kentucky 10
Read Related
Comments
who could honestly vote for the ACC.
if you have the best conference, then you should at least have a team that has a remotely decent chance at making the MNC game.
by jsholt969 on Dec 1, 2008 2:36 AM EST 0 recs
Or have 10 teams that are better than your 3rd place team...
by FSUncensored on
Dec 1, 2008 12:19 PM EST
up
0 recs
don't think I said that the SEC was the best conference.
I’m referring to what conference is the best in the nation, not whether the SEC is better than the ACC.
Maybe if you’d wipe those tears away from the pounding you just received from an SEC team, you might be able to read what I said.
by jsholt969 on
Dec 1, 2008 2:14 PM EST
up
0 recs
There are 10 teams in the ACC that could beat Ole Miss and/or Georgia
Name ’em.
But, again, jsholt’s point is a good one: The ACC isn’t the best conference. Neither is the SEC.
Team Speed Kills. All SEC, all the time.
by cocknfire on
Dec 1, 2008 3:53 PM EST
up
0 recs
Hey SEC, don't be so hard on yourselves...
At least you had the foresight to install an intelligent 3-way “tiebreaker” provision…
by Law Buckeye on Dec 1, 2008 5:00 PM EST 0 recs
My take...
The ACC impressed me last weekend. Is it the best conference? No, because it’s hard to forget about the early season OOC embarrassments such as Marylands loss to MTSU or Georgia Tech’s close call against Gardner-Webb. It’s also easy to see after watching Florida-FSU that the top of the ACC is not where near Florida and Alabama. However, you have to admit it has a lot of solid teams, even if some of them took a little while to get it together. And lest we forget, the SEC’s calling card has been parity for many years now, so I think we should give credit where credit is due.
Who is the best conference? The Pac-10 is not good this year. The Big 10 is kind of like the ACC in that it has several good teams but it’s best aren’t anywhere near as good as the best of the Big XII, SEC, and Southern Cal. The Big XII South has some good teams, but the rest of the conference is only average to bad. To be honest, I don’t think the SEC is considerably worse than any of the other conferences, but at the same time it’s certainly not better. As usual, we’ll need to wait until the end of the bowls to really know who deserves bragging rights.
Garnet and Black Attack: A Blog by and for Gamecocks Fans. http://www.garnetandblackattack.com
by Gamecock Man on Dec 1, 2008 9:35 PM EST 0 recs
The Big XII is the best conference right now
There’s no shame in saying that. Every other BCS conference is down, anyway; you have to go to the Mountain West to find another conference that is ‘up’ from last season. Conference strength is cyclical; the SEC had a great run for a few years and now—due to several factors such as coaching upheaval and young players—it is in a down stretch. I mean, more than half of the teams in the SEC don’t even play competent offense, and there’s only two complete teams anyway in the conference—but I digress.
by The ArchDawg on Dec 1, 2008 11:54 PM EST 0 recs










